Transcendence
Director: Wally Pfister
By Alex Watson
How is humanity to going to survive in the future? That is a question raised in numerous movies in the past, but there is also a notion of how we can evolve beyond human form. Director Wally Pfister this week, brings us an interesting presentation that does indeed make us wonder it if is possible for the human conscience to exist elsewhere, and what the potential repercussion are of allowing this in his movie, Transcendence. A long time collaborator with Christopher Nolan, this marks Pfisters debut in the directors chair, but with a high quality A-List cast behind him, this could prove to be something to remember!
Dr Will Caster (Johnny Depp) is a scientist who presents a radical notion, that in the future he can create a type of artificial intelligence that can control everything- including the human conscience. After he is murdered by an anti-techology group, his loyal wife Evelyn (Rebecca Hall) and his colleague Max (Paul Bettany) upload his conscience onto a computer and it evolves and grows rapidly! But although the computer of Will states it wish make the world a better place, his true intentions soon start to raise questions.
Despite a promising trailer campaign, the end product of Transcendence falls way short of the mark and we are left with a picture that despite some impressive ideas, leaves us very puzzled. Pfister shows some good touches as director and his previous cinematography experiences present us with some beautiful and cutting edge moments, but underneath all the visual flair, the movie is a bit of a mess and fails to make most of the heavyweight cast of which it is given.
The main story is straight of Christopher Nolan country and the initial stages it makes for an provocative argument of just how far humanity can go beyond a cognitive state- but before long the movie trips up on its ideals and the logical begins to become muddled, which confuses the action on display and leaves us with a rather flat after taste. Will is a man whose curiousity about the universe has cost him his own life, but when transferred to a computer, his mind quickly runs wild leading him and everyone he holds dear down a dangerous path. There are some nice mystery elements to be found in Pfisters film but they are few and far between, and by the bizzare and underwhelming climax we have begun to lose interest.
An undercooked side story of the terrorist group RIFT lead by Bree (Kate Mara) is an addition which fails to truly add something special except a statement of how technology is taking over our lives, another sideshow involving Joseph (Morgan Freeman) working with the FBI also doesn’t raise the stakes. The main issue here, is the weak script by Jack Paglen which feels disorganised and due to this fact, the dialogue feels wooden and cliched. Pfister gives this movie his best shot and in some ways it is a shame that the end result has not met the expectations because he does show brief flurries of being an able director in the future.
Johnny Depp is as always watchable, but even this man cannot elevate the picture to where it needs to be, but he does still have great presence that both draws and frightens us as we debate Will’s true intentions. Rebecca Hall does well as his devoted wife Evelyn and she handles the emotional side of things skillfully and in the third act, she demonstrates Evelyn’s gradual disillusion with how the idea has come out tremendously. Morgan Freeman is as usual, the wise man trying to avert disaster, but Paul Bettany does better in support and his horror at seeing what his friend Will has become is finely conveyed and proof he is one actor you can rely on in these type of pictures.
Transcendence is a movie that in more experienced hands could have been remarkable, but tragically we have to settle for what we currently see. It is unfair to dismiss Pfister after one effort, so I will reserve judgement for the time being on this man. But this does make us think about what is the future for the human race? And just how much will AI affect us?